Need Score Opinions on Two Deer

[UncleCharlie]

These two deer will both be shot this year as 7 year olds. Yes, they have ear tags as both were born in a breeder pen and turned out into the pasture as yearlings. Not everyone's cup of tea, I know, but am more interested in seeing what you think these deer will score.

We have some guys coming to hunt in November and I have a pretty good idea what these deer will score based on sheds from previous years but am looking for more opinions.

Thanks in advance.


DEER #1






Deer #2

[texashunter56]

From those pics I would say upper 150's to 160 on the narrow buck and low 170's on the wider buck.

[3DW5]

#1 will be around 160
#2 will be around 165
Great looking deer....

[lab man]

1st deer mid 170s
2nd deer mid 160s

[lab man]

What do you have them scoring UncleCharlie?

[Big pig]

1st deer mid 170s
2nd deer mid 160s

Curious, why do you care?

[lab man]

Care? I really don't care. Just curious since he said he already had a good idea what they scored.

Also figured I would bump it to the top since he only got a couple replies.

[artrios]

I'd say both are mid 160s