Originally posted by Rubi513
View Post
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Electrical question
Collapse
X
-
Last edited by Terran28; 06-18-2021, 05:44 AM.
-
Originally posted by Terran28 View PostGuys, I understand my first comment to the OP was wrong in the eyes of electricians, but just stating I have never seen that (and until i just researched, thought it was wrong). I was taught differently by my dad. You be courteous to the "other guy" and use properly color coded wires to distinguish the circuit. If you HAVE to use different colored wires, you wrap tape around the ends of the wire to let them know it is a load bearing wire (black or red tape).
I have heard of technicians walking away from jobs because of this. They didn't want to become the liability because someone assumed that the white wire was a neutral.
Comment
-
Bowlife has the right idea here. Y’all’s answers of liability for using a black and white wire to run a 240v circuit are ridiculous. 94% of commercial work uses the whole rainbow for conductors, just gotta check it with a meter. If you’re worried about someone thinking it’s a neutral because the wire is white just refer back to the Natural Selection page in the Book Of Life
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Comment
-
Originally posted by texasforever View PostBowlife has the right idea here. Y’all’s answers of liability for using a black and white wire to run a 240v circuit are ridiculous. 94% of commercial work uses the whole rainbow for conductors, just gotta check it with a meter. If you’re worried about someone thinking it’s a neutral because the wire is white just refer back to the Natural Selection page in the Book Of Life
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Comment
-
Originally posted by Terran28 View PostNo, I am not. I have worked with my dad in HVAC for 30 years. Never have I EVER seen a 240 volt circuit use white/black/bare. I did research it and found no codes that state you cannot, however this is asinine and should have codes for it. If I see white/black, that is a 120 volt circuit. I will use my voltmeter to determine voltage, but If I see 240v running through black/white, I will walk away from it and tell them to get someone else or have an electrician rewire it with the proper 12/3 or 10/3 depending on load.
Comment
-
Originally posted by texasforever View PostNEC applies the same in all applications
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Speaking of code, the code only specifically mentions 5 “colors” and how they should be used:
Orange B phase of a 240 V Delta system indicating a “high leg” where it measures 240V to ground. White or grey to indicate a grounded conductor (neutral) and green or bare to indicate a grounding conductor.
It does allow provisions for marking the wires regardless of color such as with phase tape.
Even most modern residential wiring no longer uses the white as a switch leg which was a poor practice to begin with.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro
Comment
-
Originally posted by Mike D View PostSpeaking of code, the code only specifically mentions 5 “colors” and how they should be used:
Orange B phase of a 240 V Delta system indicating a “high leg” where it measures 240V to ground. White or grey to indicate a grounded conductor (neutral) and green or bare to indicate a grounding conductor.
It does allow provisions for marking the wires regardless of color such as with phase tape.
Even most modern residential wiring no longer uses the white as a switch leg which was a poor practice to begin with.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro
I agree, white as a switch leg is a horrible idea. On the other side of that running 10/3 or 8/3 for an A/C application is just a plain waste of money. Not a single unit out there that needs to utilize a neutral as all are straight 240 not 240/120. Only thing I could see that being useful is if the install tech wanted a 120v GFCI mounted inside the unit for servicing the unit. Most of the time what I run into is dual black conductors and a green, if three phase you might get lucky and have marking tape for the different phases providing it’s not a delta system like mentioned. In the OP’s application I personally don’t see a need to distinguish between the different legs or have a neutral, systems gonna run the same if it’s black on black or black on white.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Comment
-
First of all, assuming that color of a wire is an indication of voltage is bad practice in all cases. Most people are correct that you don't typically see a 2 wire romex in a 240v, single phase application. On the other side of that, most residential 240v, 1 phase loads use some sort of small 120v load for a timer or a clock or something, and they need the neutral. This necessitates the 3/c - w/gnd. I have dealt with every color of the rainbow, and colors with tracer stripes. If it concerns you to phase tape the white and use it as a current carrying conductor, then pull a 3/c romex. In the end, its your place and you want to be happy and comfortable with it.
Comment
-
Originally posted by WTucker View PostGotta love electrical threads where non-electricians jump in to give wrong advice. It’s always good to make sure you are talking with a licensed journeyman/master electrician when looking for advice.
Comment
Comment