Cull or not

[Full Throttle]

This guy looks pretty old to me. Guesstimates on age/score?

[Walker]

I'd say he's on the downhill slide

[Drycreek3189]

Not the best pics for aging but going off of his neck I’d say he’s 4.5 or more. Pretty decent mass for a drought year too.

[brokeno]

Looks really old to me.

[Full Throttle]

Cull or not





Better profile pic and a close up

[Big pig]

Definitely not a cull
Old trophy buck
Good luck

BP

[PoppinPiggies]

No idea on score but I would put him on the hit list

[buck_wild]

Cull?? Do you have 150' inch regularly running around ? If not then I don't; think he's a "cull".

Now I do think he's a mature and if he floats your boat- sure whack him but unless you answered Yes above then I wouldn't say "cull.

[Greenheadless]

As others have said, old monarch trophy.

Cull8ng is a fallacy in most situations.

[Walker]

I'd "cull" him. Probably doesn't breed anymore and one less mouth to feed. He's old, old, old.

[MtnMike]

He is no doubt a Mature Buck, if he stepped out I would send it!!

[wdtorque]

This

definitely not a cull
old trophy buck
good luck
bp

100%

[txbowman12]

As far as age, I'd say "plenty old". Agree with the other comments on whether or not he is a "cull". That's an old monarch who's fooled a lot of hunters in his life, and if you get a chance to put an arrow through him, that's a trophy all day. But I recognize some leases have different terminology, and he looks 6.5 plus to me.

[Johnny Dangerr]

Defiantly a shooter...

[Full Throttle]

I’m kinda leaning the same way. Not the biggest deer by a long shot, but he’s had a good long life. Want to see him in person before deciding, but I may go ahead and put him down if he shows up.