You make the call

[Archery1st]

Whack him quick!

[ATXBowhunter]

I think that he's a shooter, esp. in light of his nature...take him out!

[Wac M Trac M]

man you got some nice deer on your place. He's as big as he's gonna get no doubt. I'd try to catch him when those awesome bucks are not around and slam him. Good luck!!!

[qzilla]

Let me tell you this. Right now, if any deer walked out in front of me I would kill it.

Does that help?

[MooseontheLoose]

Shoot him if you can. IF he is 4.5, hes not a very good one for where your at. Let the better bucks get to the protein and do the breeding.

[aironeout]

He wouldn't have a cut dogs chance in a sc^&*(ng match on our place. airhimout.

>E

[texasaggiebowhunter]

haha, he's got some issues with his aggression is what it sounds like to me. kinda like little man syndrome or something. it must be nice to see them bucks fight so often. I personally have never seen a fight in the wild. Also, personally, would take him.

[Cajun Blake]

RIP .... Idiot buck .. >>>----------> TWACK

[Split Arrow]

If it were my deer herd I would be inclined to take him out because I would think he will end up breeding more than the bucks of better quality, and he may well hurt some of the bucks I'd rather hang on the wall - like that big wide 12.

x2

[Keith]

I think he's older, maybe 6.5 or 7.5 and I would kill him no matter his age. I am sure he's breading the does, and I wouldn't want more of his genetics around.

[CountryBoy]

I would have toshoot him!!!

[Jet Black]

dirt nap

[Bubba]

dirt nap

X2

[Jamesl]

I would whack him.

[AF Slayer]

say night, night Gracie!! Whack him...