Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Deer lease openings - beware

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Deer lease openings - beware

    Okay folks, if it isn't already up on Craigslist, it will be soon. You may find in the coming days/weeks a few openings on the Hat Ranch in Concho County, 2200 acres near O.H. Ivie Reservoir. BEWARE. Ted McKnight passive-aggressively pulls the strings over there while Kevin Brown, his SIL fills the spots and sells the place to newbs.

    Kevin is a good guy put in a bad spot by his FIL. Kevin is contractually obligated, that's the reason he is still involved. I hunted there for three seasons and things were never what I was sold. Here's what you can expect:

    Contract: There is no contract or agreement. You will be told the way things are operated and two days before the season opens (after you have paid your money), you will get an email stating how things will truly operate. Of course, nothing like what you were initially told.

    Price: We were told $3,000 per gun which is already above market value for the quality (or lack thereof) of the deer herd. You will find out a month or two after the season ends, you also owe for TPWD fees, insurance, water, elec, propane, repairs, etc. That bill isn't cheap.

    Hunting: The deer numbers are decent but declining rapidly due to decades of mismanagement. It is the most ridiculous thing I have ever experienced. The property is L3 MLD but you will be allotted no more than your State license worth of tags. Of that allotment, McKnight will control all of them. You will be required to shoot all your does (whatever that # is) in October before any buck tags will be issued. McKnight doesn't allow buck hunting in October at all, gun or bow. Once your does are killed in October, he will allow you one buck tag. That buck must be 5.5+ ys/o in order to get a second buck tag (which you will have paid for). The problem is, the age structure is SO FREAKIN' SCREWED UP from decades of mismanagement, there are very few mature bucks sighted throughout the season. Year 1, I saw one. Year two, I saw one. Get the picture? The buck-to-doe ratio is jacked up too so, you will see about 10 junky bucks to three does. You will never see that second buck tag. The MLDP is changing in 2017 so, McKnight will have much more control over tags and surveys so, from experience, I suspect only three deer tags will be issued this coming season (1 buck, 2 doe). That is purely speculation on my part.

    Communication: Communication is one sided while frequent and full of nothingness. When you get correspondence, it is never good news for the hunters. You will be inundated with new rules and restrictions on a regular basis and snide comments will be tossed around freely regarding the hunters' lack of knowledge. By the end of the season, your handshake agreement will be but a distant memory and these emails are used to incrementally chip away at it until it is no more. Getting McKnight to answer a question, any question, is like getting Hillary Clinton to admit what is on her private servers. If you are not going to like his response, he will simply ignore your concern and do it repeatedly until you get the point.

    Hunting Group: For the most part, the remaining group is good people. There are two family friends that "hunt" on the place that the Game Warden knows on a first name basis for numerous infractions. The rules do not apply to these two guys. When they step outside the lines, the rest of the group is penalized while the perpetrators are free to offend again and again. And, they DO. These guys ride around all night drunk as hell and shoot "varmints" (rabbits) around people's feeders with AKs and ARs like that is acceptable. Again, rules don't apply to them.

    Property: The ranch is a nice place and could be far better if there had been any betterment over the last 40 years. The only repairs made on the ranch are those the hunters perform. All the water troughs are broken and empty, the roads are horrid and the camphouse plumbing and septic are archaic. McKnight uses the guise of being a "naturalist" to not perform any improvements to the ranch. Rattlesnakes are EVERYWHERE, including the front porch of the camphouse and in the barn. The place appears abandoned because it has been neglected for so long.

    Attitude: McKnight is a quail guy. He told me straight to my face, "If I could afford this place without deer hunters, you people wouldn't even be here. Financially speaking, deer hunters are a necessary evil." He will let you know that any chance he gets. He is also no friend to bowhunters. He has a negative view of us. He will not permit shooting bucks during bow season. He never did explain that one to me.

    Summary: This is my personal experience on the lease. Others may have a differing view but there is a reason 5 hunters have left in two years. All cited the same things I have just written. I just wanted to inform everyone to try to keep others from wasting much valued time and money as we did.

    #2
    Bump... thanks for the heads up

    Comment


      #3
      So in a nutshell......Have a written agreement in hand before handing on cash.

      Is the FIL holding a gun to the SIL's head making him do shady shat?
      Last edited by Traildust; 04-29-2017, 01:39 PM.

      Comment


        #4
        Originally posted by Traildust View Post
        So in a nutshell......Have a written agreement in hand before handing on cash.

        Is the FIL holding a gun to the SIL's head making him do shady shat?
        To be perfectly honest, I don't think a contract would change a thing over there. He has such a negative view of all deer hunters, he will do as he pleases. The SIL has a contract with them. What he didn't count on was the FIL rushing in and demanding things be his way no matter what. You'd have to know the FIL. He has a way of making you want to scoop out your own eyes with a spoon.
        Last edited by Livin'2hunt; 04-29-2017, 01:45 PM.

        Comment


          #5
          Sorry to hear your pains. One day I hope to find that perfect lease. I just think it will be a few years away once my son is out of college. A more expensive lease might help the owner/manager appreciate you a bit more.

          Comment


            #6
            Originally posted by dfkoon View Post
            Sorry to hear your pains. One day I hope to find that perfect lease. I just think it will be a few years away once my son is out of college. A more expensive lease might help the owner/manager appreciate you a bit more.
            This place is "that place" everyone recalls negatively. The place where. everyone learns hard lessons. He will appreciate nothing. I appreciate the sentiment but I landed on a good place so, all's well that ends well. Hope you get back to hunting soon.

            Comment


              #7
              And you stayed for three years?

              Comment


                #8
                Originally posted by rtp View Post
                And you stayed for three years?
                My thought too.

                Comment


                  #9
                  Originally posted by flyby View Post
                  My thought too.
                  For my kids. They loved it there and we couldn't find any place at all during that time. I only have a few years hunting with my kids, I let them enjoy it while I put up with the bad stuff. Found a new place and I bailed. If good leases were readily available, I would have stayed only one season. But alas, this is not the case.

                  Comment


                    #10
                    Originally posted by Livin'2hunt View Post
                    For my kids. They loved it there and we couldn't find any place at all during that time. I only have a few years hunting with my kids, I let them enjoy it while I put up with the bad stuff. Found a new place and I bailed. If good leases were readily available, I would have stayed only one season. But alas, this is not the case.
                    Understood. Priorities! :-)

                    Comment


                      #11
                      Actually, it's already listed on TPWD. I was on this place a few years ago. I hunted one season with my two sons. The OP is spot on. For example, the northern portion of the lease has a lot of older 4 points for some reason. "They" don't want them shot because they don't fall in the management guidelines and they could grow into something. That's the honest truth...heard it with my own ears after I commented on how there was a major problem with obviously old 4 points. I could go on FOR HOURS but I won't waste anyone's time. I'll just say this...do not make the mistake I did.

                      Edit: I hunted this place in 2014....not a few years (seasons) ago.
                      Last edited by PVDT; 04-29-2017, 04:10 PM.

                      Comment


                        #12
                        Is it even legal to make leasees pay the tpwd fees for the lease or insurance? I can see the others but not those two.

                        Comment


                          #13
                          I have hunted leases for 45 years - have been on the current one ten years. I have always said that the number one criteria for a good lease is a good land owner. You can have a great deer herd, great camp, etc. but if the land owner is one who wants you money but doesn't want you there then the rest of it is irrelevant. Also a contract/agreement is essential IMO. Sorry you had a bad experience.

                          Comment


                            #14
                            Contract: There is no contract or agreement
                            You will find out a month or two after the season ends, you also owe for TPWD fees, insurance, water, elec, propane, repairs, etc. That bill isn't cheap
                            If I was told $3k then that's what I would pay, not having a contract works both ways. Good luck getting extra hidden fee's from me after the fact.

                            He told me straight to my face, "If I could afford this place without deer hunters, you people wouldn't even be here. Financially speaking, deer hunters are a necessary evil." He will let you know that any chance he gets.
                            Sounds like a grumpy old man, probably just one bad year away from loosing the whole thing
                            Last edited by Catarina; 04-29-2017, 04:39 PM.

                            Comment


                              #15
                              Originally posted by Catarina View Post
                              If I was told $3k then that's what I would pay, not having a contract works both ways. Good luck getting extra hidden fee's from me after the fact.



                              Sounds like a grumpy old man, probably just one bad year away from loosing the whole thing
                              You don't know how close to the truth you have landed. The place has been surveyed and fenced preparing for an emergency sale.

                              I remember you PVDT. As you know, on when dealing with the owner, knowledge of the subject matter (game management) is your enemy. He likes the "don't ask questions" and "make no waves" sort of personalities.

                              The same season PVDT was on the lease, the two family friends whom I refer to as Goober and Gomer found or were handed the remaining MLD tags and they invited 8 of their buddies to the ranch for a weekend of wholesale slaughter. Not a word was said to them all the while, I was reprimanded for shooting a 6.5 y/o 7 point.

                              AVOID IT AT ALL COSTS PEOPLE!

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X