Out of the three which would you take?

[Monster Buck]

If these were the only three bucks you could shoot which one would it be? Age,score and reason you picked that one.
I know there is going to be a lot of let them go,get older but that is not a option in this question.

[NotJose]

3rd, seems to b heaviest. I'm not great w/aging, but seems the oldest as well

[pblaetz]

I think 2 and 3 are the same deer?

[crowmagnum]

Nope 2nd a 9 pt & 3 is an 8.(I thought so to thus the edit)lol!

[Black Ice]

Out of the three which would you take?

2 and 3 look similar to me. But with saying that 3 looks like he's older than 2, but I think it's the way he's standing and it's the same deer.

[txtimetravler]

3 BC he looks older and is farthest from camera

[fishycatfish]

#1, he has more character and I like crab clawed 8 points. Looks like he may be the youngest but you made me pick one lol. 110-115. #2 looks to have the most potential.

[Sleepy]

I think 2 and 3 are the same deer?

Pics 2&3 are the same buck.I'd shoot pic 1

I don't think they are. Pic 2 has a crab claw on his left side, pick 3 doesn't

[Black Ice]

Out of the three which would you take?

I'm an idiot, deer 2 had more points that deer 3 lol.


Pass on one and two and shoot 3.

[bow4my2]

#3, oldest and heaviest

[blntrey3]

#3 is best deer.....but has most potential, so i would kill #1 and let other 2 grow unless they were on others hit list and I would stick to #3

And I would consider #1 a Cull imho

[krtnorris]

1

[Black Ice]

#3 is best deer.....but has most potential, so i would kill #1 and let other 2 grow unless they were on others hit list and I would stick to #3

And I would consider #1 a Cull imho

I'm sooo confused


1 would not be a cull for me.

[GarGuy]

I would kill the first one... the first one to show up that is.

[bowtecmike]

what GarGuy said