Score and Age please

[devalke]

I have these two shooters coming to the feeder twice a day, sometimes 3 or 4 times a day and I'm having a difficult time deciding which one to poke.

Can you give me some WAGs on each ones score and age? I refer to them as the "Tall 9" and "Wide 8".

Thanks

[texashunter56]

The wide 8 buck is older but both are mature. Shoot which ever buck you like. I prefer taller narrower bucks...more real estate and less airspace.

[texasdeerhunter]

I think they are the same age, or the 8 may be a year older. Both look mature. And score wise, I believe both are within 2-4 inches of 132. I would shoot whichever one shows up first haha! Good luck

[devalke]

I like them both. Like you I like the tall ones but then the 8 has webbing between the points which I like and may help with the score. Since I have no clue on scoring "on the hoof" though I would get a few guesses to help me decide.

Thanks for the reply

[Ronnie41]

Why not both

[devalke]

Parker county only allows 1 per year

[Arrow Slinger]

I think the 8 is older. That would be my target animal. Good luck.

[Hoss163]

Wide 8 5.5 and 128 tall 9 4.5 and 130

[walker1983]

If they both walk in at the same time - shoot whichever one looks bigger to you.

I wouldn't wait on one vs the other - both shooters. 128-132 ish..

[RMW]

I personally like the wide buck better and he looks 6.5. Tall narrow buck is probably older with them wore out knee pads, rare to see them that wore on a buck.

[devalke]

I personally like the wide buck better and he looks 6.5. Tall narrow buck is probably older with them wore out knee pads, rare to see them that wore on a buck.

Interesting, I didn't even notice that. Thanks for pointing that out. Something learned on TBH today

[devalke]

anymore guesses on age and score?

[rattler03]

4.5 on age for both, but if one is older its the wider deer. score is about 125 on both of them. I like the wider deer, but you can't wrong with either of them. both very nice 8-pointers

[BolilloLoco]

9pt 4 & 120
8pt 5 & 125

[jason86]

Shoot which ever gets sideways first