Mature buck?

[Pokes21]

What ya think?








Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Krautzy]

I'd shoot him

[Antlers86]

I want to say 4 yr old and a dang good one. Tarsals don’t have much staining, skinny face, back is straight, brisket looks to just starting to develop

Any past history with him?

[Jnorth]

Looks 4.5 to me. Nice deer.

[Hoss163]

Looks 4.5 5 at most

[Pokes21]

I want to say 4 yr old and a dang good one. Tarsals don’t have much staining, skinny face, back is straight, brisket looks to just starting to develop

Any pst history with him?

Nope only two pics of him. The issue I have is if i see him I let him walk we have hunters to the west and north of us and I know they would take him. Just curious if he would grow next year.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Antlers86]

Nope only two pics of him. The issue I have is if i see him I let him walk we have hunters to the west and north of us and I know they would take him. Just curious if he would grow next year.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Just a gamble you have to take. Me on a lease I wouldn’t hesitate. Me on home property would just depend on neighbor relationship. I have a really nice 4 yr old at my home property. Can’t say I wouldnt shoot him if I see him. My wife and kids will take him if they see him. At some point hunting needs to be just that....hunting. If it makes you happy, gets your heart thumping then enjoy that moment and take the deer.

[Pstraw]

If he dies this year he won't grow any more.

[Pokes21]

Just a gamble you have to take. Me on a lease I wouldn’t hesitate. Me on home property would just depend on neighbor relationship. I have a really nice 4 yr old at my home property. Can’t say I wouldnt shoot him if I see him. My wife and kids will take him if they see him. At some point hunting needs to be just that....hunting. If it makes you happy, gets your heart thumping then enjoy that moment and take the deer.

No doubt about that statement! My heart gets pumping for a doe I take lol


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[GREATWHITE416]

Not mature yet.

[wes122984]

3 yo

[HotRod Hunter]

I’d have to say 4

[buck_wild]

Nope only two pics of him. The issue I have is if i see him I let him walk we have hunters to the west and north of us and I know they would take him. Just curious if he would grow next year.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

That's weird cuz the hunters to the west and north of you both said they have hunters to the east and south of them that would shoot him It's a viscous cycle that can't be broken unless all can get on the same page and communicate about deer but that doesn't/can't happen very often.

[Mexico]

No

[Passthrough]

Walk him....definitely not gonna get mature if YOU kill him.FTR I think he looks 4 as well.