Spike - To remove from the gene pool or not.

[bear]

right or not, I would think about backstraps if that rascal was under 30yds

[happy bowhunter]

He's probably a late born 1.5yr old, let him walk

X2

[FIREFIGHTER16]

Knock it down

[Encinal]

Show me another deer you are calling a yearling

[timbobowhunter]

take him out

[strangmusic18]

I would let him walk. You can't judge what he really will look like until the velvet sheds. He looks thick antlered for a spike but I would think that is just the velvet mass. If you can afford to let him walk, let him walk.

[W-L-F]

what is your deer density??? if you would not miss him shoot him---i do agree that he is young; not sure of a yearling; more in line of a 2.5 thats another reason to smoke him---just my opion

[ArcheryAddict]

Let it walk.

[Bokil]

He'll score about 20. Oh wait that's not the question.

[mikemorvan]

Interesting. The vote is nearly exactly split. I guess he's going to get to try again next year. I'm in an antler restricted county. Of the pictures i have so far, he's the only marginal buck. The other bucks i've got pictures of are either good, to pretty good. With age and nutrition, etc. the others all have a chance to be really, really good. We'll give him a year and see what he does. Bad news for a couple of does. Thanks for the input.

[top pin]

If he's 2.5 and under don't shoot him.

[Miki]

In the2nd picture he looks 2 1/2. YOu will just have to see in in person.

[Encinal]

Kill him if he is 2... leave him if he is 1

[denimdeerslayer]

I would take that one out of the herd.

[GCFSLLC]

Needs to be SHOT!!!!!!!!