Any lawyers on here licensed in AZ?

[The Crippler]

The plaintiff signed the petition, not Silviano. Anyone can file a petition in justice court, it looks like Silviano maybe helped prepare it but isn't representing the plaintiff. This is the most ridiculous thing I've seen. The stupid thing is that it was filed in justice court, and (at least in Texas) the justices aren't licensed to practice law and anything can happen. I tell clients if they get sued in justice court to save their money and try the case themselves - if they win, great, if they lose, just appeal to a higher court and it starts all over with a judge that is a lawyer and understands the law. I am not licensed in Arizona, but my suggestion would be to look into the appellate procedure in this matter. It is my opinion (not legal advice) that a Motion to Dismiss would take care of this in a higher court, the petition just doesn't make sense, I don't know that this plaintiff has standing to bring an "insurance fraud" cause of action.

[DJM]

Truck was stolen Aug 2014 while I was out of town on business

Do you have anything documenting that you were out of town working and not in Mexico?

DJ

[iamntxhunter]

At any point did your insurance company settle with you on the vehicle? Was there any affidavit signed by you upon settlement with the insurance company?
This would appear to be a situation that could be cleared up with minimal effort. Craziest thing I have ever heard of.

[trjones87]

Truck was stolen Aug 2014 while I was out of town on business

Do you have anything documenting that you were out of town working and not in Mexico?

DJ

i have a video of my daughter in junction tx the day he claimed we made the exchange

At any point did your insurance company settle with you on the vehicle? Was there any affidavit signed by you upon settlement with the insurance company?
This would appear to be a situation that could be cleared up with minimal effort. Craziest thing I have ever heard of.

Yes they settled with me. not sure on the affidavit

[Stuck]

****. Just checked this thread again to see what has been so interesting the last couple of days. I see y'all have gotten Cripsol banned.. He sure was adding a second layer of interesting to the thread. Good thing he has that second account.

[systemnt]

I told him it wouldn't end well for him........

[Burnadell]

I told him it wouldn't end well for him........

For the record, I had nothing to do with it!

[Grayson]

****. Just checked this thread again to see what has been so interesting the last couple of days. I see y'all have gotten Cripsol banned.. He sure was adding a second layer of interesting to the thread. Good thing he has that second account.

Poor guy was banned with 666 posts.

[flyin7]

I thought your insurance would be breeching their contract if they didn't protect you from being sued.

[Graysonhogs]

For the record, I had nothing to do with it!

Plausible deniability.

[SabreKiller]

Dem is some ugly women!

As one TBH'er has said, "This won't even sniff the docket".

[2050z]

For the record, I had nothing to do with it!

why can I hear you laughing then???? LOL

[RR 314]

Transaction purportedly took place in Mexico.
You live in/were served in Texas.
Plaintiff lives in Arizona.
Plaintiff sues you for just under jurisdictional limits in play court.
Cheese-ball guy in Jeep sports white shorts, likely before Easter, and says pay up, sucka!

File MTD, plea to jx, and cite Pennoyer v. Neff, International Shoe and any case you can find with a Japanese tire company as a party. That will do. :-)

Bottom line. . . if we had that dang wall built in 2014 none of this would have happened.

[trjones87]

Transaction purportedly took place in Mexico.
You live in/were served in Texas.
Plaintiff lives in Arizona.
Plaintiff sues you for just under jurisdictional limits in play court.
Cheese-ball guy in Jeep sports white shorts, likely before Easter, and says pay up, sucka!

File MTD, plea to jx, and cite Pennoyer v. Neff, International Shoe and any case you can find with a Japanese tire company as a party. That will do. :-)

good stuff there

Bottom line. . . if we had that dang wall built in 2014 none of this would have happened.

amen

[trjones87]

I thought your insurance would be breeching their contract if they didn't protect you from being sued.

"The policy does not provide coverage of intentional acts, which the lawsuit is alleging."
-USAA